Many bids fail not on price but on documents. Knowing the evaluation order helps prepare a bid that passes, and if you lose for the wrong reason, when and how to object.
How bids are evaluated
- Construction evaluation methods: the merit point system (technical and price weights, for complex work), lowest price pass/fail, and lowest price with a technical threshold. The method and weights are in the package’s tender documents.
- Arithmetic correction applies to unit-price contracts. A bid above the owner’s estimate (HPS) after correction is rejected. For lump-sum contracts the price in the offer letter stands.
- A unit price well above the HPS unit price (in practice usually above 110%; the exact limit is in the tender documents) is unbalanced and is clarified; if it stays unbalanced it applies only to the bill of quantities volume.
- A bid below 80% of HPS after arithmetic correction gets a price reasonableness check. If unreasonable it is rejected; if reasonable, its performance guarantee becomes 5% of HPS.
Example: HPS Rp1.2 bn
| Situation | Result |
|---|---|
| Corrected bid Rp936 m (78% of HPS) | Price reasonableness check; have unit price analyses ready |
| If found reasonable | Performance guarantee Rp60 m (5% of HPS), not Rp46.8 m (5% of the bid) |
| Unit price Rp1,150,000 against an HPS of Rp1,000,000 | 115%: likely treated as unbalanced and clarified |
| Filing an appeal | Appeal guarantee Rp12 m (1% of HPS) |
Objection and appeal
| Step | Deadline | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Objection (sanggah) | Filed through SPSE within 5 calendar days of the award announcement, ending on a working day and hour | The Pokja answers within 3 calendar days after the objection period ends |
| Appeal (sanggah banding) | As scheduled in SPSE and the tender documents | Only for construction and integrated work; with an appeal guarantee of 1% of HPS; answered by the budget authority (KPA); stops the tender |
| KPA answer | Within 14 calendar days of receiving confirmation of the appeal guarantee (LKPP Regulation 3/2026) | The old rule said 14 working days |
Legal basis for government projects: Perpres 16/2018 as last amended by Perpres 46/2025, and LKPP Regulation 3/2026 (set in September 2026, replacing LKPP Regulation 12/2021). Tenders started before the new rule and contracts already signed still follow the old rule and their contract terms. The new rule also focuses on bidders’ beneficial owners, collusion and "borrowed flag" bidding. Electronic guarantees with a valid e-signature and e-stamp no longer need a paper original. Always check the SPSE schedule and your package’s tender documents, because those are binding.
Common reasons bids fail
- The bid guarantee is late, the wrong amount, or its issuer cannot be verified through LPSE.
- The same staff member proposed by two bidders, so all are rejected.
- Staff competence certificates (SKK) expired, or equipment capacity not as required.
- An incomplete construction safety plan (RKK).
- A work method identical to another bidder’s, which can be evidence of collusion.
Common mistakes when objecting
- Filing after the objection period in the SPSE schedule has closed. Since LKPP Regulation 4/2024 the period is 5 calendar days, not the 5 working days many older guides give.
- An objection with no reasoning that points to the tender documents.
- Forgetting the 1% appeal guarantee, or filing an appeal for procurement other than construction.
The full guide is in How to build a construction cost report that catches overruns early. It has a free template (Excel or Google Sheets) and a checker that reads your own workbook.
Ready to use the Komander agents on your projects?
When your workbook is complete, apply for a pilot: we help connect your project data to the Finance, Cost and Scheduler agents and review the first reports with you.
Send to melwani@komander.ai. Your workbook check result is included when there is one; the workbook itself is not sent.
Common questions
How long is the objection period?
Five calendar days after the award announcement, ending on a working day and hour, filed through SPSE. The exact dates are in the tender schedule in SPSE.
How large is the appeal guarantee?
One percent of the owner’s estimate (HPS), and appeals apply only to construction and integrated work.
What happens to a bid below 80% of HPS?
The Pokja checks whether the price is reasonable. If not, the bid is rejected; if so, the performance guarantee becomes 5% of HPS.
References
- LKPP legal database: LKPP Regulation 3/2026 (Indonesian): procurement guideline
- Rajah & Tann: LKPP Regulation 3/2026: main changes and effective date